City bumble bees outbreed their country cousins

bombus terrestris_Tony Wills, some rights reserved (CC BY-SA) B_inaturalist 960x
Buff-tailed bumble bee (Bombus terrestris) / Photo: Tony Wills,

Bumble bees placed in urban areas produce more offspring than colonies in agricultural areas, concludes a surprising new study. The research, led by academics from Royal Holloway University of London and including an Imperial College London researcher, is published today in the journal Proceedings of the Royal Society B.

Despite the fact that urban areas are usually seen as being less friendly to wildlife, this study showed that bumble bee colonies actually grew better when placed in the urbanized London area than surrounding agricultural sites.

Bumble bees are important pollinators but are facing multiple threats, including changes in the availability to forage because of land-use change and pressure from parasites and disease. Finding what controls their breeding success is therefore important.

Ph.D. student Ash Samuelson, from the School of Biological Sciences at Royal Holloway, set out to discover why: Is it that bees simply move into urban areas, or are urban bee colonies more successful and able to produce more offspring?

Agricultural impacts on wildlife

Colonies of wild bumble bees were reared in the lab at Royal Holloway and placed into 38 gardens and farms across the south of England from inner city London to farmland in Berkshire. The bees were then monitored over a ten week period.

Ash said, “We found that bumble bee colonies placed in agricultural areas produced significantly fewer reproductive offspring than those in villages or city sites. This means that these colonies would be less able to pass their genes on to the next generation. We also found that agricultural colonies were smaller and had less stored food, which may have contributed to the lower reproductive success.

“Although it seems counterintuitive that the ‘unnatural’ environment of a city is beneficial to bees, we have to remember that modern agricultural areas are also very far from the habitats in which these bees evolved. So while we were surprised by the magnitude of the effect of urbanization on bee colony success, the fact that bees performed poorly in farmland reflects the increasingly apparent realization that intensive agriculture has negative impacts for wildlife.”

Abundance of flowers

The abundance of flowers throughout most of the year in gardens and parks may help explain why the bees thrive, while the loss of wildflowers plus crops that flower for a short time in agricultural areas may mean bees have fewer resources. The use of pesticides on agricultural land could also have a negative impact on the health of colonies.

Co-author of the study Dr. Richard Gill, from the Department of Life Sciences at Imperial, said, “Understanding how human-induced land use change affects bumble bees is vital in developing the best mitigation strategies to protect our future pollination service providers.

“These results suggest that we may need to focus more attention on supporting bumble bees in areas of heavy agricultural practices. And whilst this study does not suggest that urban environments are necessarily havens for bees, there must be components of the urban landscape that we can use to inform conservation strategies and land management practices.”

Reprinted and lightly edited from Imperial College London news release.